How is motive used in criminal cases in Qld?

Introduction

In Queensland criminal law, motive refers to the reason behind an alleged offence. While motive can sometimes appear significant, it is usually not required for the prosecution to prove a charge. However, in certain serious offences such as murder or arson, motive may still become relevant when the evidence is circumstantial.

What is motive?

The courts have described motive as “the reason that nudges the will and prods the mind to indulge the criminal intent.” In simple terms, motive is why a person acts, while intent is the decision to act.

For example, a person may intentionally assault another without the prosecution needing to prove why they did it. The law focuses on proving that the act was committed intentionally or unlawfully, not the reason behind it.

Is motive necessary to prove an offence?

No. In Queensland, the prosecution generally does not need to prove motive. Section 23(3) of the Criminal Code 1899 (Qld) provides that, unless expressly stated otherwise, motive is immaterial to criminal responsibility.

This means that in offences such as:

  • Murder – the prosecution does not need to prove why the act occurred

  • Assault – the police do not need to show a reason for the attack

The primary question for the court is what happened and whether it was unlawful or intentional, not why it happened.

When can motive become relevant?

Motive may become relevant in circumstantial cases, where the prosecution relies on indirect evidence to suggest guilt. In such cases, motive can form part of the chain of reasoning the prosecution asks the jury to consider.

Examples of motive in circumstantial cases

  • Arson – an insurance policy taken out shortly before a suspicious fire

  • Fraud – evidence of financial stress suggesting a reason to obtain money dishonestly

  • Homicide – allegations involving jealousy, revenge, or relationship breakdown

  • Retaliation – prior disputes, such as a drug debt, used to suggest motive for an assault

The High Court in De Gruchy v The Queen [2002] HCA 33 confirmed that motive, if proven, may be a fact from which a jury can infer intention. Conversely, an absence of motive can sometimes assist the defence in arguing that the prosecution’s case is incomplete or lacks credibility.

Why motive is not enough on its own

Even if the prosecution presents evidence of motive, that alone is not sufficient to prove guilt. Juries are often directed that motive is only one piece of evidence and cannot, by itself, establish criminal responsibility.

In R v Gaskell [2016] QCA 302, the Queensland Court of Appeal noted that jury directions about motive depend on the specific facts of each case. Judges will typically remind jurors that strong evidence of motive does not replace the need for proof beyond reasonable doubt.

Likewise, the absence of motive does not mean a person is innocent, a conviction can still be based on other compelling evidence.

Key takeaways about motive in Qld

  • Motive is not required to prove most offences in Queensland.

  • It may arise in circumstantial cases as part of the prosecution’s reasoning.

  • Motive cannot alone prove guilt without supporting evidence.

  • A lack of motive does not automatically mean there is no case.

Choosing the best criminal defence lawyer in Brisbane

Our criminal defence lawyers appear daily in Brisbane and Queensland courts for serious criminal offences. We are available for a confidential discussion about your case. No booking required.

📞 Speak to our leading Brisbane Criminal Lawyers on (07) 3012 6531. You can also request a confidential callback by filling in our Quick Enquiry form, which also includes access to our free guide 16 Things You Need to Do Now if Charged with a Criminal Offence.

The information on our website is general in nature and does not constitute legal advice. Please contact our criminal law team for specific advice about your case.

Last updated November 2025.

Amy Soong

Amy Soong - Legal Practice Director - Accredited Specialist in Criminal Law

Amy Soong is the founder and Legal Practice Director of Ashworth Lawyers and a Queensland Law Society Accredited Specialist in Criminal Law. Established in 2014, Ashworth Lawyers is a Brisbane-based criminal defence firm focused exclusively on representing clients facing serious and complex criminal charges throughout Queensland.

With over 18 years of experience in criminal defence, Amy leads the firm's team in the preparation and conduct of complex criminal matters in the Magistrates, District and Supreme Courts, with particular experience in serious sexual offences, drug trafficking, fraud and violent offences.

Specialist Accreditation is one of the highest professional credentials available to solicitors, recognising advanced knowledge, skills and substantial experience through a rigorous assessment process conducted by the Queensland Law Society. Only approximately 3% of criminal lawyers in Queensland hold Specialist Accreditation.

Amy is also recognised by Doyle's Guide as a Recommended Leading Criminal Defence Lawyer, with Ashworth Lawyers recognised as a Recommended Leading Criminal Defence Law Firm in Queensland. Amy holds a Bachelor of Laws (Honours), Bachelor of Business (Accounting) and Master of Laws from QUT. She has also completed the Bar Practice Course and is currently undertaking a Graduate Diploma in Information Technology (Artificial Intelligence) at QUT.

Beyond her practice, Amy is a member of the Queensland Law Society Wellbeing Working Group, regularly contributes articles to Proctor and has presented on criminal law topics for Legalwise and at the Queensland Law Society Symposium. She was also a finalist for Entrepreneur of the Year at the 2023 Lord Mayor's Multicultural Business Awards and Executive of the Year at the Lawyers Weekly Women in Law Awards.

 

https://www.ashworthlawyers.com.au
Previous
Previous

What is ‘Felony Murder’ in Qld?

Next
Next

What is Rape & Affirmative Consent in Qld?